On Thursday, January 30, 2025, the San Antonio Express-News reported that Andrew Carruthers, the longest-serving judge in Bexar County, is retiring after 35 years of dedicated public service. At the age of 79, Carruthers made a significant mark in the judicial system, becoming the first criminal law magistrate and the first Black magistrate in the county’s history.
Carruthers began his career as a defense attorney and assistant district attorney before being appointed as the first Bexar County criminal law magistrate in 1989. He was selected from nine candidates to handle pretrial motions in contested felony cases and to accept felony guilty pleas. His appointment came at a time when Texas judges were facing heavy caseloads and needed additional support.
Throughout his tenure, Carruthers has presided over half a million cases, establishing himself as a respected authority in competency and sanity issues. He has also served as an assistant professor at the Thurgood Marshall School of Law, contributing to the education of future legal professionals.
Carruthers is known for his innovative approach to the judicial process. He was a pioneer in implementing teleconferencing and video conferencing in court proceedings, which became especially beneficial during the COVID-19 pandemic. By allowing mental health evaluations to be conducted virtually, he helped reduce costs and streamline the judicial process. Carruthers emphasized that this innovation not only saved money but also eliminated the need for experts and inmates to testify in person, reducing transportation and logistical challenges.
His commitment to improving the justice system is evident in his work to establish inpatient and outpatient competency restoration programs, ensuring that individuals with mental illnesses and developmental disabilities receive the necessary support to stand trial. Colleagues and legal professionals have recognized Carruthers for his significant contributions to mental health advocacy, both within Bexar County and across Texas.
At a recent portrait unveiling ceremony held on January 15, judges, attorneys, and various officials gathered to celebrate Carruthers’ remarkable career. Attendees spoke highly of his integrity, kindness, and intelligence. Judge Sid Harle, who was part of the panel that appointed Carruthers, expressed confidence in his qualifications, stating that there was no doubt he was the right choice for the position.
District Attorney Joe Gonzales acknowledged Carruthers’ pioneering efforts in the mental health field, noting that his rulings have consistently exemplified fairness and a commitment to justice with compassion. Other judges and colleagues shared personal anecdotes highlighting Carruthers’ mentorship and support throughout their careers.
Carruthers has built lasting relationships with his staff over the years, maintaining a close-knit working environment. His court coordinator, Angela Martinez, praised his humility and approachability, recalling how he always made time for those seeking his guidance. Martinez even chose Carruthers to officiate her wedding, demonstrating the deep respect and affection his colleagues have for him.
As he prepares for retirement, Carruthers has expressed a desire to travel, with plans to explore Africa and Europe. He looks forward to experiencing new adventures and enjoying leisure activities like skiing and golfing. His longtime court reporter, Roxanne Peña, who has worked alongside Carruthers for 32 years, announced her retirement to coincide with his, describing him as “the legend” and highlighting the unique bond they shared.
Carruthers’ departure marks the end of an era in Bexar County’s judicial landscape. His contributions to the court and the community will be remembered as he leaves behind a legacy of commitment to justice and compassion for those he served.
Source: San Antonio Express-News
