On Thursday, March 13, 2025, the Michigan Judicial Tenure Commission issued an order directing the Master overseeing the disciplinary proceedings against Judge Demetria Brue and Judge Debra Nance to schedule a public hearing. This order mandates that the hearing process be completed by July 1, 2025.
The formal complaints stem from allegations of misconduct related to an incident that occurred on August 20, 2019, during a judicial conference at the Mackinac Island Bike Shop. Reports suggest that Judge Brue, accompanied by Judge Nance, confronted the shop owner about an issue with a rented bicycle and subsequently attempted to seize a receipt, leading to accusations of assault and racism. Both judges involved are African American.
The recent order underscores the urgency of the situation, as the Commission aims to ensure that the hearing process moves forward promptly. The Master is expected to set a date for the public hearing without delay, aligning with the court’s directive to conclude the proceedings by the specified deadline.
Disciplinary counsel previously filed a motion requesting coordination of hearings for both Judge Brue and Judge Nance, emphasizing the need for efficiency due to the overlapping nature of the cases. Counsel indicated that many witnesses are anticipated to testify in both hearings, and scheduling them consecutively would minimize the burden on those involved. The motion sought to address logistical challenges, given that witnesses are located in various parts of Michigan and even out of state.
During a prior status conference, discrepancies in testimony related to the allegations were identified, particularly in statements made months after the incident. The Master overseeing the cases acknowledged potential misunderstandings but noted the necessity for clarity regarding the allegations against both judges.
The disciplinary counsel’s brief highlighted the importance of expediting the hearings, arguing that delays could compromise the integrity of the process. They expressed concern over the need to address Judge Nance’s claims about her opportunities to resolve her allegations without a public hearing. Disciplinary counsel asserted that all judges facing similar charges have the same options, including the possibility of resignation to avoid public proceedings.
Additionally, a report from the National Center for State Courts referenced in the disciplinary counsel’s brief indicated that while there are racial disparities in judicial discipline cases, it did not suggest that Black judges lack equal opportunities to address allegations outside public forums.
The order from the Michigan Judicial Tenure Commission reflects the court’s commitment to uphold judicial accountability and ensure that the allegations against Judge Brue are resolved in a timely manner. As the Master prepares to set the date for the public hearing, the judicial community and the public await further developments in this high-profile case.
A copy of the original filing can be found here.
