The New York Advisory Committee on Judicial Ethics has issued an opinion stating that a criminal court judge may speak at a youth program organized by the local police department. Opinion 25-158 addresses the scenario where the judge was invited to tour the youth program and share insights about their career path and personal life.
The audience will consist of middle and high school students from local schools and community organizations. The judge’s presentation would include their experiences as a survivor of child abuse and academic and socio-economic challenges. The event is sponsored by a non-profit charitable foundation that supports police innovation, community engagement, and public safety.
The Committee referenced the rule that judges can speak, lecture, and teach if it doesn’t interfere with their judicial duties or compromise their impartiality. The Committee has previously allowed judges to share personal and professional experiences at various forums, including those affiliated with law enforcement.
The Committee concluded that, given the circumstances, the judge’s participation is permissible. The opinion clarifies that a judge is allowed to discuss the law, their personal experiences, and career trajectory at a youth program supported by a law enforcement agency, provided that the judge adheres to standard limitations.
