On Tuesday, January 14, 2025, ABC15 published an interview with Arizona Supreme Court Chief Justice Ann Timmer, discussing the qualities that define a good judge. The conversation covered various topics, including judicial ethics, court-packing allegations, and essential personality traits for judges.
Chief Justice Timmer emphasized the importance of not being result-oriented in judicial decision-making. She stated, “I’ve developed my own strategy of not being result-oriented because that’s a disaster, ultimately.” Timmer highlighted that focusing solely on outcomes can lead to complications in future cases, urging judges to rely on legal principles to guide their conclusions.
According to Timmer, effective judges possess the ability to maintain an open mind and actively listen. She stressed that humility is crucial, acknowledging that judges do not have all the answers and that others may offer valuable insights. “The best judges are the ones who can keep an open mind and listen,” she stated.
The Chief Justice also spoke about the significance of adhering to an ethical code in the judiciary. She noted that Arizona’s judicial system has established a framework requiring judges to comply with specific ethical standards, backed by a judicial conduct commission that oversees complaints against judges. This code, she asserted, distinguishes state courts from the U.S. Supreme Court, where such regulations may not be as stringent.
The interview touched upon the evolution of the Arizona Supreme Court, which has expanded from three justices in 1912 to seven justices today. Timmer referenced House Bill 2537, signed into law by former Governor Doug Ducey in 2016, which allocated funding for the addition of justices. Critics raised concerns about court-packing; however, Ducey defended the move as necessary for ensuring “swift justice.” Timmer initially expressed skepticism about the need for more justices but has since recognized the benefits of the expansion, particularly in responding to the state’s growth and enhancing diversity within the court.
Timmer expressed concern about the accessibility of the judicial process for everyday citizens. She articulated her desire to leave a legacy focused on expanding meaningful access to justice within Arizona, highlighting the importance of community involvement in the legal system.
Source: ABC15
