In the shadowed corridors of our justice system, what happens when those in power break the rules they’re sworn to uphold—or ignore the pleas of those they’re meant to protect?
Michigan’s Judge Joseph Slaven offers a troubling case study. Accused of unprofessional conduct—from obscene gestures toward surveillance cameras to publicly undermining his chief judge—Slaven’s defense reads more like a manifesto than a legal rebuttal. He claims his behavior, including printing campaign flyers and renaming files provocatively, was all part of a strategy to expose court surveillance abuses. Whether it’s whistleblowing or weaponizing chaos, the spectacle erodes public trust and turns courtrooms into arenas of ego and accusation.
Meanwhile in Ohio, a father’s desperate petition pierces through layers of judicial indifference. Timothy Tucker is fighting to delay the sentencing of his son, Joshua, whose mental health conditions require accommodations that the court has allegedly ignored. When judges refuse to acknowledge psychiatric evaluations or block a caregiver from assisting in a defense, they don’t just bend procedure—they risk irreparable harm to vulnerable defendants. It’s a reminder that legal systems often stumble hardest when confronting invisible disabilities.
But not all judicial decisions are made in the dark. In New York, an advisory committee demonstrated the value of ethical clarity by approving a part-time judge’s secondary employment—provided safeguards prevent conflicts of interest. It’s a simple gesture, rooted in transparency, but one that reinforces how careful oversight can guide judges without compromising justice.
Three stories. One system. And a sobering truth: the robe alone doesn’t guarantee righteousness. Accountability, empathy, and restraint must do the rest.
Disclaimer: The news on Abusive Discretion is from the public record. Editorials and opinions are light-hearted opinions about very serious topics not stated as statements of fact but rather satirical and opinion based on the information that is linked above.
