On Wednesday, October 29, 2025, WAFB 9 News reported that the family of Madison Brooks appeared in the 19th Judicial District Courthouse in Louisiana to advocate for the recusal of Judge Gail Ray from a case involving Casen Carver.
Carver is the driver of the vehicle that Brooks was in on the night of an alleged sexual assault that preceded her death in January 2023. The hearing took place before Judge Brad Myers, who is expected to issue a ruling on the recusal motion this week.
The central issue prompting the recusal request stems from Judge Ray’s prior knowledge of evidence deemed inadmissible by an appeals court. This evidence includes details regarding Brooks’ sexual history, which the higher court ruled should not be introduced during the proceedings.
During the recusal hearing, a contentious exchange unfolded between prosecutors, defense attorney Joe Long, and Judge Myers. Long represents Casen Carver, who faces charges related to being in the vehicle with Brooks on the night in question, but is not accused of sexually assaulting her. Carver is one of three individuals indicted following Brooks’ death and declined to comment after the hearing.
Outside the courthouse, Ashley Baustert, Madison Brooks’ mother, expressed the profound grief her family continues to experience. She emphasized her desire for a fair trial for her daughter, highlighting the broader issue of victim-blaming in legal proceedings. Baustert noted the defense’s historical tendency to shift blame onto victims by referencing their behavior or attire.
District Attorney Hillar Moore acknowledged the difficulty of the decision facing Judge Myers. Moore stated his belief that Judge Ray should not preside over the case, citing her previously expressed conviction that certain evidence, later deemed inadmissible, should be considered. Moore questioned how Judge Ray could disregard her prior stance and maintain impartiality, given the First Circuit and Supreme Court’s rulings against the admission of the evidence.
The legal proceedings aim to address the circumstances surrounding Madison Brooks’ death and the alleged sexual assault. The recusal hearing represents a critical juncture in ensuring a fair and impartial trial, free from the influence of previously considered and ultimately rejected evidence. The decision by Judge Myers will significantly impact the direction of the case and the pursuit of justice for Brooks.
Source: WAFB 9 News
